ADMINS
Kenton Ngo
Johnny Camacho
Aimee Fausser
EDITORS
Bryan Scrafford
Adam Sharp
DanielK

BlogRoll
STATEWIDE
Bearing Drift
Blue Commonwealth
BlogNetNews
CobaltVA
Not Larry Sabato
Raising Moran
VAPoliticalBlogs

NORTHERN
7 West
Albo Must Go
Anonymous Is A Woman
Anti-BVBL
Blacknell
Blueweeds
Getting Around
Leslie Byrne
Left of the Hill
Ox Road South
Raw Fisher
Renaissance Ruminations
The Green Miles
Too Conservative
X Curmudgeon

HAMPTON ROADS
Shad Plank
VBDems
Vivian Paige

CHARLOTTESVILLE
Democratic Central
Rick Sincere
Rule .303
Shaun Kenney
Waldo Jaquith

RICHMOND
SlantBlog
Save Richmond
Tertium Quids

SOUTHSIDE
Dem Bones
What IS Right For Virginia
220 South

VALLEY
Adam Sharp
RockDem
The Friendly City
The Valley Progress Report

SOUTHWEST
Rick Howell Speaks
Star City Harbinger

Death to the Incumbent Nomination Advantage

by: Kenton Ngo

Sat Jan 09, 2010 at 09:20:15 PM EST


Normally when more than one candidate from the same party files for an office, the political party committee for that district chooses between a primary, convention, or caucus. Virginia has a rather peculiar law which allows incumbents facing a same-party challenger to choose a nominating method.

This is, on its face, insane. Republican Delegate Lee Ware has pre-filed a bill to repeal this incumbency bonus, but it remains to be seen whether 140 incumbents want to vote away their best weapon against upstart intra-party challenges.

Invariably the incumbent--who typically has better name recognition--will choose a primary, and win. Very rarely do incumbents in this state find themselves overthrown in a primary (Delegates Bob Hull from 2009 and Gary Reese from 2005 come to mind, but they are exceptions).

Both parties have areas of the state with heavy one-sided party alignment, but eliminating the incumbent advantage in nomination contests is more important for Democrats, who have a stranglehold on majority-black districts that often reach up to 70-90% Democratic performance. Senators and Delegates who are elected in single-party areas of the state are practically guaranteed their seat until they give it up, and can choose whatever method of nomination they believe will be most advantageous to them.

Of course, this doesn't eliminate any pro-incumbent bias in the political party committees that would make this selection--but that's the party's problem. I hope that Virginia's legislators have the courage to eliminate the statutory incumbent protection.

Kenton Ngo :: Death to the Incumbent Nomination Advantage
Tags: (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email
Choose a primary?
Since you're the numbers guy, do you have any stats on that? Because in Norfolk, that hasn't been the case. They have chosen caucuses instead.

Recent Diaries

Menu

Make a New Account

Username:

Password:



Forget your username or password?


Syndicate
RSS 2.0
Tip Jar

EMAIL
Send tips & press releases to:
[email protected]

Search




Advanced Search


LeftyBlogs Latest

The views expressed on this site are representative solely of the author, and do not necessarily imply endorsement by New Dominion Project staff.
Powered by: SoapBlox